Maserati Ghibli Forum banner

1 - 5 of 5 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
42 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
It specifically mentions Maserati and Chrysler, a good read for more perspective on part sharing:
http://www.automobilemag.com/features/columns/1403-the-dark-art-of-parts-sharing

For automakers, sharing components is a bit like engaging in unsafe sex. Everyone knows it can produce unwanted and long lasting consequences, and yet most everyone does it anyway. Automakers, being businesses, have a primal urge to make more money. Saving money on parts that are going to be similar anyway sounds sensible—natural, even. After all, who’s really going to care if, say, Chrysler and Maserati share navigation systems?

Car reviewers care, of course. We are the ultimate prudes when it comes to parts sharing. We pass through so many vehicles that commonalities most people miss—or at least choose to ignore—become bothersome to us. And as enthusiasts, we loathe the watering down of the distinct sensory experiences that make certain cars special. Maseratis that have Chrysler navigation systems may be better at directing you to a destination, but they feel less like Maseratis.

Yet the notion that automakers should abstain from sharing parts, especially in an era when car development is becoming more costly and complicated, is a quaint and unrealistic one. Better, then, to come up with some guidelines for safe and responsible parts sharing.

Don’t share parts we can see.
Automakers have mostly internalized this one—the sort of badge engineering that was common in the 1970s and 1980s is now rare. And yet, there are new vehicles that wear their shared parts all too blatantly. Take a look at the BMW Active Tourer that’s debuting at the Geneva auto show. Sure, it wears brand-correct cues and kinks, but that stubby nose broadcasts the fact that this Bavarian has been slumming with front-wheel-drive Minis.


Don’t share parts everyone can feel.
The Lincoln MKZ looks different from a Ford Fusion, probably at no small expense. And yet from behind the wheel, there's simply no mistaking it for a Ford Fusion. It raises the question: why not just buy a Ford Fusion?

Automakers often dig themselves a deeper hole by downplaying the extent of such under-the-skin sharing. Executive editor Todd Lassa remembers Pontiac representatives insisting the Grand Am was sportier than the Oldsmobile Alero, but declining to explain how. “When I pushed them on it, they said it had something to do with the seat mounts,” he says.


DO share parts you cannot make better on your own.
It should be noted that in the right relationship, parts sharing can be harmless—beautiful even. Few fault modern Bentleys for using Audi components. Why? Because Audi components are pretty great. The fact that Bentley doesn’t have to engineer and produce its own platforms and powertrains frees it to spend its resources on stuff it's uniquely good at, like hand-stitching fine leather hides and selecting wood veneers.

Design editor Robert Cumberford, who himself long ago tried to develop his own low-production automobile, adds that some small firms source parts as a means of survival “because doing your own taillight might cost more than the rest of the project.”

Don’t use a part for something completely different than its original use.
Question: What do you get when you re-orient the front suspension of a Chevrolet Citation? Answer: The rear suspension for a Pontiac Fiero.
Do disregard any and all advice if the car is fantastic.
We’d rather have a Scion FR-S and Subaru BRZ that are identical than not have them at all. We’re happy to drive an Audi R8 that shares its guts with a Lamborghini Gallardo. We’re quite certain we’ll be just fine with a Mazda Miata that’s related to an Alfa Romeo. Smart parts sharing, like so many elements of car development, is very subjective.

Senior editor Michael Jordan remembers that many Ferraris, until recently, used Fiat switchgear. “It never bothered me because when you're driving a Ferrari at an appropriate speed, you shouldn't be looking away from the road, eh?”
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
852 Posts
Interesting article with some good guidelines. and the point is made that you should not use parts we can see but ones that are good that we cannot develop ourselves....which rules are in conflict...and you can argue that unconnect is not the best but it is very functional and gave Maserati the ability to deliver the Ghibli at the price they did...........yes and the Chrysler switchgear which doees not buy itself make the interior look like a Chrysler.........
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
348 Posts
This has gotten so out of control with people knocking the Ghibli for using Chrysler switch gear. You know what???…..IF FITS AND LOOKS GOOD AND WORKS. The Quattroporte uses the EXACT same switchgear and you don't see many reviewers bitch about in that car. The Ferrari California uses the same window switches and headlight switches and I have NEVER seen a review bitch about it in there…was at the dealer yesterday and specifically looked at Ferrari for this reason…what's more, the new Ferrari will use UConnect also.

Reviewers are simply trying to find ways to punch holes in the Ghibli to protect their precious Germans (Audi, BMW mainly) who have a habit of "taking care" of the well known journalists…giving them cars for months, flying them to launch events and putting them up at hotels, wining and dining them, etc.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
"Reviewers are simply trying to find ways to punch holes in the Ghibli to protect their precious Germans (Audi, BMW mainly) who have a habit of "taking care" of the well known journalists…giving them cars for months, flying them to launch events and putting them up at hotels, wining and dining them, etc." - anderson

Politics are everywhere.

I had Radio Shack switches I mounted in my late '70 something Toyota Corolla to turn on my Bosch fog lights LOL!!!!

Who cares...?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
324 Posts
Reviewers are simply trying to find ways to punch holes in the Ghibli to protect their precious Germans (Audi, BMW mainly) who have a habit of "taking care" of the well known journalists
Exactly. Maserati is an absolute threat to the Germans. It doesn't take very many percentage points of market shift toward Maserati (and Alpha) to seriously cut BMW's profit margins. And Maserati is on track to meet or exceed their goal of 50k units for 2015. My guess is the vast majority of those 50k would otherwise have been German. This of course does not include future lost sales from lesser models to Alpha. Fiat is going to the mattresses and you can bet that BMW et al is taking it seriously... and so are all the fanboy journos who're on the payroll.
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top